Fatigue, Impairment & Dangerous Behavior

Driver-related factors are present in roughly one-third of all fatal large truck crashes. These factors fall into three categories: fatigue caused by hours-of-service pressure and undiagnosed conditions, impairment from drugs or alcohol, and dangerous behaviors like distraction and speeding.

Key Findings
  • 160K+

    Injuries from large truck crashes annually

    NHTSA FARS 2022
  • 28%

    Inspected trucks had brake violations

    CVSA Roadcheck 2023
  • 23×

    Higher crash risk when texting at the wheel

    FMCSA Research
  • 153K+

    Drug & alcohol violations in Clearinghouse

    FMCSA Clearinghouse 2025

Select a topic below to expand its articles.

Reference

Driver Error vs. Carrier Liability

Factor Driver Liable Carrier Liable Both Liable
Hours-of-service violation (isolated)
HOS violation with systemic carrier pressure
Drug use, unknown to carrier
Drug use, carrier ignored red flags
Distracted driving (personal phone use)
Speeding on tight carrier schedule
FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Yes. NHTSA’s data showed that 27% of policyholders from five warm-weather states (Texas, California, Louisiana, Florida, and Arizona) accounted for 77% of all tire-related insurance claims nationwide, and 84% of those claims involved tires older than six years. Tires in hot climates age at rates several times faster than tires in temperate regions because the rate of the oxidation reaction increases exponentially with temperature.
  • Aged tires fail through two primary mechanisms. Tread separation occurs when the rubber between the steel belts loses its adhesion, causing the tread cap to peel away from the carcass suddenly and without warning at highway speeds. Sidewall blowout occurs when oxidized sidewall rubber fails under the flex loading of each rotation, resulting in immediate and complete loss of air pressure. Both failure modes are often preceded by no visible warning.
  • Michelin recommends that tires be thoroughly inspected annually after five years of service and replaced 10 years after their date of manufacture, regardless of remaining tread depth, including spare tires. Ford and Chrysler added warnings to their owner’s manuals in 2006 stating that tires should be replaced after six years of service. The British Rubber Manufacturers’ Association recommended that unused tires not be put into service if they are over six years old.
  • Rubber compounds degrade over time through thermo-oxidative degradation, in which heat and oxygen cause the internal rubber components to stiffen, crack, and lose their ability to flex under load. This degradation occurs whether the tire is in active service or sitting in a warehouse. Oxygen permeating through the inner liner reacts with the rubber compounds even when the tire is not being driven. Spare tires showed degradation patterns similar to on-road tires of comparable age.
Continue Exploring
  • Mechanical Failures

    Brake defects, tire blowouts, cargo securement, and maintenance failures that cause catastrophic crashes.

    Explore
  • Driver Error

    Fatigue, impairment, and dangerous on-road behavior—and the systemic pressures behind them.

    Explore
  • Crash Evidence

    The critical window for preserving physical and electronic evidence before it disappears.

    Explore
  • Company Liability

    How carrier hiring practices, training failures, and cost-cutting create conditions for preventable crashes.

    Explore